Book a consultation

Case study

Driving Efficiency with Technical Upgrades and Smart Investment

Production line speed optimization: how we found the automation and process limits on a high-volume line and delivered a double-digit throughput gain.

Vladimir Romanov


Sector
Consumer packaged goods
Location
Auburn, ME
Client
Confidential
Read
9 min

Project Overview

One of the biggest challenges at a Procter & Gamble site where our team was executing projects was a capacity constraint. The first question was whether it was more economical to increase the speed of existing lines or to purchase and deploy additional lines. The second was to understand what it would take technically to substantially increase the speed of production lines that already ran at high speed. The project was structured in phases, beginning with R&D to determine the limits of increasing line speed, followed by cost analysis for deploying additional lines, and finally evaluating the investment required to roll out the first phase across multiple lines if the R&D results were positive.

Introduction

Manufacturers often face the challenge of balancing rising demand with capital investment decisions. At one Procter & Gamble site, the production team faced a critical capacity constraint. Leadership needed to determine whether it was more cost-effective to invest in entirely new production lines or to increase the performance of the existing ones. Joltek was engaged to lead the technical and business evaluation, develop a clear business case, and manage the execution of key upgrades.

Long row of winding heads spooling white yarn onto bobbins along a production line
Before buying another line, find out what the one you have could do: the business case starts with the limits of existing equipment.
ProblemWhat we didOutcome
Demand forecasts showed current capacity would soon be insufficientBuilt a business case comparing new lines with faster existing linesLeadership received a comprehensive comparison of incremental upgrades against new line investment
Unknown technical limits to running existing lines fasterR&D on drives, vision inspection and synchronization, with controlled trials under increased loadsData showing which upgrades were necessary and which were optional
Upgrades had to be delivered without disrupting ongoing productionManaged integrators and electrical crews, supervised commissioning and testing, trained operators and maintenanceA double-digit increase in throughput on the upgraded line, with major capital expenditure deferred and a roadmap for the other lines

The Challenge

The site operated modern, high-speed production lines, yet demand forecasts showed that current capacity would soon be insufficient. Leadership faced two pressing questions:

  • Was it more economical to increase throughput by accelerating existing lines, or would additional lines be required?
  • If line speed increases were viable, what technical modifications and investments would be necessary to achieve stable performance without compromising quality or reliability?

This project demanded not only deep technical expertise but also a rigorous business case to weigh capital costs, operational risks, and long-term scalability.

The Approach

Phase 1: Business Case Development

We began by assessing both options side by side, on the same terms: line speed increases versus new line deployment.

  • Financial modeling was conducted to compare capital expenditure for new equipment against the incremental cost of upgrading existing lines.
  • Scenario analysis considered downstream impacts such as material supply, staffing, and utility requirements.
  • ROI evaluation framed leadership’s decision-making around both short-term gains and long-term flexibility.

This ensured the project was not just a technical exercise, but also a strategic investment decision.

Business case questionWhat was compared
Capital costCapital expenditure for new equipment against the incremental cost of upgrading existing lines
Material supplyThe downstream impact of more output on material supply
StaffingThe downstream impact on staffing
UtilitiesThe downstream impact on utility requirements
ReturnShort-term gains against long-term flexibility

Phase 2: Technical Feasibility and R&D

The R&D effort focused on identifying system constraints that limited line speed. Our team worked alongside OEMs and integrators to:

  • Analyze VFDs and servo drives for performance and failure risks at higher operating speeds.
  • Test Cognex vision systems to ensure product inspection could maintain accuracy at faster throughputs.
  • Evaluate bottlenecks in synchronization between equipment and control logic.
  • Conduct controlled trials to validate system behavior under increased loads.

This phase provided leadership with data-driven insights into which upgrades were necessary and which were optional.

From a capacity constraint to a faster line: the three-phase approach A capacity constraint raises two questions: is it more economical to speed up existing lines or add new ones, and what would a speed increase take technically. Phase one, the business case, compares capital for new equipment with the incremental cost of upgrades, models downstream impacts on material supply, staffing and utilities, and frames the return. Phase two, technical feasibility and R and D, analyses drives and servo axes, tests vision inspection at faster rates, evaluates synchronization between equipment and control logic, and runs controlled trials. Its output sorts upgrades into necessary and optional. Phase three, execution, manages integrators for PLC and SCADA work, coordinates electrical crews, supervises commissioning and trains operators and maintenance. The result is a double-digit throughput increase on the upgraded line, deferred capital expenditure and a roadmap for the other lines. Capacity constraint: demand would soon outrun the existing lines Faster existing lines, or new lines? And what would a speed increase take technically? 1 · Business case new-line capital vs upgrade cost material supply, staffing, utility requirements short-term gains vs long-term flexibility frames the decision in money 2 · Feasibility and R&D drives and servo axes at speed vision accuracy at faster rates synchronization between equipment and control logic controlled trials under load necessary vs optional upgrades 3 · Execution integrators: PLC, SCADA, equipment interfacing electrical crews: drives, controls, infrastructure commissioning and testing operator and maintenance training production disruption minimized Result Double-digit throughput increase on the upgraded line. Major capital expenditure deferred. A roadmap for applying the same upgrades to the other lines in the facility.
Phase two is the hinge. Until controlled trials show which limits are real, a business case can only compare guesses; afterwards it compares costed upgrades with a new line.

Phase 3: Execution and Integration

Once feasibility was established, the project transitioned into execution. Key responsibilities included:

  • Managing system integrators responsible for PLC programming, SCADA adjustments, and equipment interfacing.
  • Coordinating electrical crews for installation of upgraded drives, controls, and supporting infrastructure.
  • Supervising commissioning and testing to validate performance under real production conditions.
  • Training operators and maintenance teams to adapt to new performance standards and equipment behavior.

Throughout execution, risk was closely managed to minimize disruption to ongoing production.

The Result

The phased approach delivered clarity and measurable value:

  • Leadership received a comprehensive business case comparing incremental upgrades against new line investment.
  • Technical upgrades were successfully implemented, including VFDs, servo drives, and vision systems, enabling substantial line speed improvements.
  • The upgraded line delivered a double-digit increase in throughput, reducing the need for additional shifts and deferring major capital expenditures.
  • A clear roadmap was developed for applying the same upgrades to other lines across the facility.

This project highlighted how aligning technical execution with business strategy can recover hidden capacity, avoid unnecessary capital spend, and extend the life of existing assets.

What Sets the Speed Limit on an Existing Line

The R&D phase looked at three areas: drives, vision inspection and synchronization. The paragraphs below explain, in general engineering terms rather than as findings from this site, why those three decide how fast an existing line can run.

Drives and servo axes. Running a machine faster asks more of every motor: higher speeds, and shorter acceleration and deceleration within each cycle. A drive chosen with comfortable margin at the original rate can sit much closer to its current and thermal limits at a higher one, and the energy returned during deceleration has to be absorbed somewhere. The rating terms that describe what a drive system can deliver are set out in the IEC 61800 series for adjustable speed drives. That is why a speed increase starts by checking each drive against the new duty, not against its nameplate.

Vision inspection. A camera inspection runs the same sequence for every product: trigger, image capture, processing and a pass or reject decision. The whole sequence has to finish before the next product arrives and before the product reaches the reject point. A faster line shortens that window and moves the product further during each exposure. An inspection that was accurate at the old rate is not automatically accurate at the new one, so it has to be tested at the target speed.

Synchronization. A line is a chain of machines and transfers, and its rate is set by the slowest link and by how well the links stay in step. Speeding up one machine moves the bottleneck to the next one, or creates accumulation and starvation between them. The control logic that coordinates the machines has to hold its timing at the new rate, which is the point of the first lesson below.

Why trials come before capital. Each of these limits shows itself only when the line actually runs faster. A controlled trial under increased load turns an assumption into a measurement, and it is what allows a business case to separate the upgrades a line truly needs from the ones it does not.

Lessons Learned

  • Integration is critical: accelerating one piece of equipment is meaningless unless the entire line can stay synchronized.
  • Business case discipline matters: leadership trusted the technical upgrades because they were framed within clear financial outcomes.
  • Cross-functional management drives success: coordinating integrators, electrical crews, and OEM support ensured the project stayed on schedule and delivered results.
  • Small component choices have large impacts: vision systems, drives, and control logic all became make-or-break factors once line speed increased.

Conclusion

Capacity constraints are inevitable in high-volume manufacturing. This project demonstrated that with the right technical expertise, business analysis, and disciplined execution, manufacturers can often find significant performance gains in existing lines without the cost of major new capital investment.

At Joltek, we specialize in bridging these worlds: combining hands-on technical knowledge with strategic insight to deliver results through strategy, alignment, and execution.

If your plant is weighing a new line against a faster existing one, this is the work we do in OEE and downtime improvement and a modernization roadmap, with commissioning support when the upgrades go in. For the technical background, see our overview of industrial controls.

References and further reading

  1. IEC 61800-2:2021 Adjustable speed electrical power drive systems. Part 2: General requirements. Rating specifications for adjustable speed AC power drive systems · International Electrotechnical CommissionHow drive ratings and performance attributes are specified, the starting point for asking whether a drive can run faster.
  2. IEC 61131-3:2025 Programmable controllers. Part 3: Programming languages · International Electrotechnical CommissionThe standard for the PLC languages in which line synchronization logic is written.
  3. ISA-95 Standard: Enterprise-Control System Integration · International Society of AutomationWhere SCADA sits between machine control and plant operations.

← All case studies

Have a project that needs technical ownership?

Send us the situation. If it is not something we should take on, we will say so.

The Plant-Side Brief

The weekly brief for the people who own a plant’s control systems.

One email every Wednesday for engineering and operations leaders responsible for controls, SCADA, MES and OT networks. Skim the top in two minutes; read the Deep Dive when you have fifteen.

  • One modernization problem, worked through to cost, risk and a schedule you can defend. The Deep Dive.
  • End-of-support dates before they reach your plant Windows, servers, controllers and HMI software. Lifecycle Watch.
  • A checklist your engineers can run that week not a framework to admire. Field Kit.
  • Every number sourced, no vendor agenda we are paid by plants, never by vendors.